10 Highest-Paid Kickers in the NFL, Ranked by AAV (2024)

When constructing an NFL team, special teams often take a backseat. While positions like quarterback, wide receiver, and offensive tackle regularly see players making tens of millions of dollars annually, teams are forced to compromise elsewhere.

It isn’t just about skill or talent; there is also a vital component of value. Teams may opt for a less qualified player if they can free up a few million in cap space, allowing for flashier moves in free agency.

Still, like all positions, kickers have a pay scale. Here are the 10 highest-paid kickers in the NFL today, based on the average annual value of their most recent contracts.

1 Harrison Butker, Kansas City Chiefs: $6.4 million AAV

Butker is coming off the best season of his career

Harrison Butker caused quite an uproar this offseason with several controversial remarks during a commencement address. But that didn't stop the Kansas City Chiefs from making him the highest-paid kicker in the NFL with a four-year, $25.6 million extension that will keep him at Arrowhead through the 2028 season.

Butker, who represented himself in negotiations, is coming off the best overall season of his career, having made 100% of his extra-point attempts for the first time since his rookie year in 2017, while also connecting on a career-high 94.3% of his field-goal attempts in the regular season.

He was then perfect during the Chiefs' run to a second straight Super Bowl victory, going 11-for-11 on field goals and 8-for-8 on extra points.

2 Jake Elliott, Philadelphia Eagles: $6 million AAV

Elliot has gained the Eagles’ trust

See Also

Top 10 Fantasy Football Kickers In 2024Kickers to target in 2024 fantasy football draftsFantasy Football Kicker (K) Rankings: 2024 DraftsCowboys' second-year kicker Brandon Aubrey performing on a 'different level'

Before Butker got his deal on August 5, Philadelphia Eagles standout special teamer Jake Elliott tied Justin Tucker as the highest-paid kicker in the league in terms of AAV, signing a four-year, $24 million extension on March 13.

The contract will keep Elliott in Philly through the 2028 season and includes $9.7 million guaranteed and a $5.54 million signing bonus. At 29, Elliot has established himself as one of the best kickers in the game and has a penchant for delivering clutch kicks.

3 Justin Tucker, Baltimore Ravens: $6 million AAV

Tucker has been well compensated for his performance over the years

For years, the Baltimore Ravens ’ Justin Tucker wasn’t only considered the league’s best kicker, but also the highest-paid player at his position, although that's no longer the case in the latter.

Like Elliott did with the Eagles this past offseason, Tucker signed a four-year, $24 million extension with Baltimore in 2022 with $14 million guaranteed at the time of the signing and $17.5 million in total guarantees.

Tucker’s latest deal runs through the 2027 campaign and will keep him under contract through his age-38 season.

4 Matt Gay, Indianapolis Colts: $5.625 million AAV

Gay’s latest deal will see him hit free agency in 2027

After winning a Super Bowl with the Los Angeles Rams , Matt Gay signed with the Indianapolis Colts in the 2023 offseason for $22.5 million over four years. The deal included an $8 million signing bonus and $13 million guaranteed.

Despite posting his lowest field-goal percentage since his rookie year last season, connecting on just 80.5% of his field goals, Gay is expected to continue being the Colts' kicker for the foreseeable future, with his contract running through the 2026 season.

5 Graham Gano, New York Giants: $5.5 million AAV

Gano has begun to show his age

Veteran kicker Graham Gano inked a three-year, $16.5 million extension with the New York Giants in 2023, which runs through the 2026 season and could possibly mark the end of his career. With around $11.335 million guaranteed, the Giants showed a lot of trust in Gano to continue producing as he approaches the age of 40.

Things have gotten off to a rocky start, though, as Gano only played in eight games last season and made a career-low 64.7% of his field goals. The small sample size could be misleading, but the contract has the potential to be a disastrous one with a repeat performance in 2024.

6 Evan McPherson, Cincinnati Bengals: $5.5 million AAV

The Bengals have McPherson locked up through the 2027 season

The Cincinnati Bengals signed Evan McPherson to a three-year, $16.5 million extension in mid-August, which will keep the 2021 fifth-rounder in southwestern Ohio through the 2027 season and includes $10 million in new money in the first year.

McPherson has connected on 83.9% of his field-goal attempts in the regular season during his career, missing just once from inside 40 yards, and has gone a perfect 19-for-19 in the postseason.

7 Dustin Hopkins, Cleveland Browns: $5.3 million AAV

Hopkins produced the second-highest point total in Browns history in 2023

After racking up the highest point total of any kicker in Cleveland Browns history in 2023, Dustin Hopkins was rewarded with a three-year, $15.9 million extension on July 15, which will keep him in Ohio through the 2027 season.

The Browns acquired Hopkins via trade from the Los Angeles Chargers ahead of the '23 campaign, and the veteran made the franchise look good for doing so, connecting on 24 of 26 extra-point attempts and 33 of 36 field-goal tries.

Hopkins' 123 points are the second-most in team history, trailing only legendary running back Jim Brown's 126 in 1965.

8 Ka’imi Fairbairn, Houston Texans: $5.3 million AAV

Fairbairn has found his stride in Houston

In many ways, Ka’imi Fairbairn of the Houston Texans had the best season of his career in 2023, as he hit 27 of his 28 attempted field goals and missed a total of two kicks the entire season.

This performance couldn’t have come at a better time for the pending free agent, who signed a three-year, $15.9 million deal to stay in Houston. Fairbairn’s latest deal comes with a $4.3 million signing bonus and $11.06 million guaranteed.

9 Jason Myers, Seattle Seahawks: $5.275 million AAV

Myers received lots of field time in 2023

After stints early in his career with the Jacksonville Jaguars and New York Jets , Jason Myers has found a long-term home with the Seattle Seahawks .

Myers made the second of his Pro Bowl career in 2022 and used that leverage to sign a four-year, $21 million extension with Seattle in 2023 with a $7.5 million signing bonus and $12.3 million guaranteed.

The Seahawks got their money’s worth out of Myers in 2023, having him attempt a league-high 42 field goals.

10 Tyler Bass, Buffalo Bills: $5.1 million AAV

Bass has left some Buffalo fans wanting more

Tyler Bass ' missed field goal in the waning moments of the Buffalo Bills ' loss to the eventual Super Bowl champion Kansas City Chiefs in the Divisional Round left a sour taste in fans’ mouths. But one play doesn’t define a player.

Bass and Buffalo agreed to terms on a four-year, $20.4 million contract extension in April 2023. The deal included $9.41 million guaranteed and will keep him with the Bills through the 2027 season.

The 27-year-old has been a solid kicker, but he hasn’t been good enough to stop Buffalo from looking for an upgrade and exploring a potential out from the contract after next season.

All stats courtesy of Pro Football Reference and all contract information courtesy of Spotrac unless stated otherwise.